Standard News

Hide Advertisement
  • Business
  • Culture
  • News
  • Technology
  • Trending
Site logo
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

U.S. judge faults Uber, bans background check in NY lawsuit

By Reuters 2 min read
Advertisement - Continue reading below
Uber logo on a vehicle near Union Square in San Francisco, California

By Jonathan Stempel

NEW YORK (Reuters) – A federal judge on Monday banned Uber Technologies Inc and its Chief Executive Travis Kalanick from using information from a background check on a passenger bringing a price-fixing lawsuit, saying the investigative firm conducting the probe may have engaged in criminal conduct.

Advertisement

U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff in Manhattan also faulted the popular ride-sharing service for hiring the firm, Ergo, at all.

Rakoff called it a “sad day” that Uber felt compelled to authorize what became an “intrusive and clandestine,” and ultimately unsuccessful, probe to unearth damaging information about the plaintiff Spencer Meyer and his lawyer.

“The court finds perfectly appropriate an order enjoining defendants from making use of the fruits of their own troubling conduct,” Rakoff wrote. “The court cannot help but be troubled by this whole dismal incident.”

Monday’s decision may end a battle over how Ergo, a New York-based firm founded by a former director of counterterrorism at the White House National Security Council, tried to help Uber and Kalanick defend against Meyer’s civil lawsuit.

Uber declined to comment. The San Francisco-based company and Kalanick have said they would agree not to use information from Ergo’s probe, so long as they did not admit wrongdoing.

Ergo and its outside lawyer did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Andrew Schmidt, who is Meyer’s lawyer, said he is pleased with the decision.

Meyer accused Kalanick of illegally conspiring with Uber drivers to coordinate high “surge pricing” fares during periods of heavy demand by agreeing to charge prices set by an algorithm in the Uber smartphone app for hailing rides.

Uber takes a cut of revenue that drivers generate. The company is privately held, but in June conducted a funding round valuing it at $62.5 billion.

Rakoff said Ergo crossed a line with lies its unlicensed investigator Miguel Santos-Neves told friends and acquaintances about Meyer and Schmidt in a bid to learn more about them.

The judge faulted the investigator for pretending to seek information about “up-and-coming” environmental conservation researchers and labor lawyers, when the real purpose was more likely to intimidate Meyer or hurt his case.

“Ergo, in investigating plaintiff, was engaged in fraudulent and arguably criminal conduct,” Rakoff wrote.

Santos-Neves’ misrepresentations, moreover, “were condoned by the highest levels of Ergo leadership,” Rakoff added.

Uber has said it hired Ergo over concerns about Meyer’s motivations for suing, including “legitimate security risks facing Uber personnel and first-hand experience with malicious lawsuits against executives at high-tech companies.”

The case is Meyer v Kalanick, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, No. 15-09796.

(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by W Simon and Bill Trott)

tagreuters.com2016binary_LYNXNPEC6O0YV-VIEWIMAGE

Advertisement - Continue reading below

First funerals held for Dallas police slain in racially motivated ambush
News
Reuters 3 min read

First funerals held for Dallas police slain in racially motivated ambush

Leading Companies and Trade Associations Catalyze New Multi-Industry Business Group to Save Federal Library Funding
Business
Jason Owen 5 min read

Leading Companies and Trade Associations Catalyze New Multi-Industry Business Group to Save Federal Library Funding

Ex-officer charged in Florida shooting death of black man
News
Reuters 2 min read

Ex-officer charged in Florida shooting death of black man

Connecticut ex-Governor Rowland’s conviction upheld on appeal
News
Reuters 2 min read

Connecticut ex-Governor Rowland’s conviction upheld on appeal

The Rolling Stones to appear in cinemas worldwide
Entertainment
Reuters 1 min read

The Rolling Stones to appear in cinemas worldwide

Social costs of Flint, Michigan, water crisis total $395 million: study
News
Reuters 2 min read

Social costs of Flint, Michigan, water crisis total $395 million: study

States on Zika’s frontline see big gaps in funding, expertise
News
Reuters 5 min read

States on Zika’s frontline see big gaps in funding, expertise

Japan’s first lady makes first visit to Pearl Harbor
News
Reuters 3 min read

Japan’s first lady makes first visit to Pearl Harbor

Planned ‘Star Wars’ museum seeking ‘locations outside of Chicago’
Entertainment
Reuters 2 min read

Planned ‘Star Wars’ museum seeking ‘locations outside of Chicago’

Starbucks accused of slashing employee work hours amid cost cuts
News
Reuters 3 min read

Starbucks accused of slashing employee work hours amid cost cuts

load more Loading posts...

sidebar

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

sidebar-alt

  • About Us
  • Imprint
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • For Advertisers