Standard News

Hide Advertisement
  • Business
  • Culture
  • News
  • Technology
  • Trending
Site logo
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

U.S. court will not scrap lawsuit over Purina Beggin’ dog treats

By Reuters 2 min read
Advertisement - Continue reading below
Nestle Purina brand dog food is pictured in Mexico City

By Jessica Dye

NEW YORK (Reuters) – A U.S. judge on Friday threw a bone to a New York man whose lawsuit claims Nestle Purina Petcare Co [NESNP.UL] duped dog owners into thinking its Beggin’ treats are made mostly of real bacon.

Advertisement

U.S. District Judge Kenneth Karas in the Southern District of New York largely denied Nestle Purina’s bid to dismiss the proposed class action brought last year by Paul Kacocha of Dutchess County, New York. The lawsuit accuses the company of violating New York consumer-protection law with its marketing of the popular Beggin’ products.

Kacocha, who owns a West Highland terrier named Sophie, said he and other New York consumers paid a premium for Beggin’ treats on the assumption that their primary ingredient was pork bacon, when in fact the meat is just a small part of the pet product.

He pointed out that the treats are meant to look, smell and resemble actual bacon – and that the name “Beggin’” sounds like the word “bacon” – despite being made primarily of ingredients like wheat, corn, water and soy.

St. Louis-based Nestle Purina, a subsidiary of Nestle SA, asked Karas to toss the case, arguing that no reasonable consumer could be misled by the products’ advertising, marketing and packaging.

But the judge said it was too early in the litigation to conclude that a reasonable consumer would know enough about what goes into Beggin’ treats to assume bacon would not be a main ingredient.

“For a product like dog food, the court is skeptical that the gradient between correctness and unreasonableness is so steep,” Karas wrote.

The ruling noted that different courts have reached varying conclusions in similar cases. Had Kacocha alleged he had viewed a Beggin’ strips ad featuring the tagline “Dogs Don’t Know It’s Not Bacon,” the judge said he might have reached a different conclusion.

Karas did, however, dismiss allegations about a statement on the company’s website stating the treats were made with bacon, noting that it was true.

Kacocha’s lawyer, Robert Berg of Denlea & Carton, said he was pleased with the court’s “nuanced and thoughtful analysis.”

Nestle Purina spokesman Bill Salzman said the company believed the court’s ruling indicated that it would ultimately prevail.

“The notion that anyone would actually think we’re selling strips of bacon is nonsense,” he said.

The case is Kacocha v. Nestle Purina Petcare Co, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, No. 15-5489

(Reporting by Jessica Dye; Editing by Anthony Lin and David Gregorio)

tagreuters.com2016binary_LYNXNPEC7B1KZ-VIEWIMAGE

Advertisement - Continue reading below

Florida man sentenced for threats against mosques
News
Reuters 2 min read

Florida man sentenced for threats against mosques

U.S. investigates steering problems in 135,000 older Toyota SUVs
News
Reuters 1 min read

U.S. investigates steering problems in 135,000 older Toyota SUVs

Baidu receives approval from California DMV to test self-driving cars
News
Reuters 2 min read

Baidu receives approval from California DMV to test self-driving cars

Schwimmer navigates choppy world of restaurants in ‘Feed the Beast’
Entertainment
Reuters 2 min read

Schwimmer navigates choppy world of restaurants in ‘Feed the Beast’

Edward Snowden talks film debut and dramatizing his life in ‘Snowden’
Entertainment
Reuters 2 min read

Edward Snowden talks film debut and dramatizing his life in ‘Snowden’

From Bhangarh Fort to Shimla’s Tunnel No
Entertainment
Ethan Blake 8 min read

From Bhangarh Fort to Shimla’s Tunnel No

Michigan prosecutor to bring new criminal charges in Flint water scandal
News
Reuters 2 min read

Michigan prosecutor to bring new criminal charges in Flint water scandal

Whitney Houston, Prince memorabilia to hit auction block
Entertainment
Reuters 1 min read

Whitney Houston, Prince memorabilia to hit auction block

Harry Potter casts spell again with ‘Cursed Child’ sales
Entertainment
Reuters 2 min read

Harry Potter casts spell again with ‘Cursed Child’ sales

This Cave Near Portland Will Leave You Speechless
Trending
David Clarke 3 min read

This Cave Near Portland Will Leave You Speechless

load more Loading posts...

sidebar

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

sidebar-alt

  • About Us
  • Imprint
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • For Advertisers